To say that all of the details intertwined with so many different people and relationships is complex would be an understatement. Supt. Allen was taken into custody on Oct. 26 by detectives on the task force after probable cause allowed it. Allen pleaded not guilty in a preliminary hearing, Carroll County Prosecutor Nicholas McLeland said in a news conference Monday. "Its somewhat bittersweet," Mike Patty, grandfather of Libby, told reporters Monday gathered at the DelphiUnited Methodist Church, "knowing it allows us to move to the next turn, the next chapter. Good job! Almost yours: 2 weeks, on us 100+ live channels are waiting. We will refer to this new informant as SPM2 for Search Party Member 2. He has the whole town on his friends list. In Indiana, most defendants are entitled to a reasonable bail that is high enough to ensure the defendant's appearance in court, according to Indiana law. It was his first appearance in public since his Oct. 28 arrest and initial hearing. We have never given up. I keep seeing people say it was a sunken bowl surrounded by a circle of trees. Kind of odd that the most descriptive mentions point out a circle of trees. Because of the nature of the victims wounds, it is nearly certain the perpetrator of the crime would have gotten blood on his person/clothing., The document says authorities also found that two articles of clothing from one of the girls was missing from the crime scene while the rest of their clothing was recovered. DELPHI, Ind. Crews were being sent out 10 to 12 people at a time to help cover an area of 20 to 25 square miles, Leazenby said. Abby Williams, 13, and Liberty "Libby" German, 14, had gone for a. Gray makes over $100,000/year from his podcasts, which is fine by me. DELPHI, Ind. "Secrecy of judicial action can only breed ignorance and distrust of courts and suspicion concerning the competence and impartiality of judges, attorneys for the media wrote, citing a Nebraska case. The revelations come just two weeks after authorities released a redacted version of the probable cause affidavit that led to Richard Allen's arrest. Still, the voice of the suspected. in which I've ever, thankfully, have had to witness anything so utterly horrible. Police initially believed the. He loves the outdoors, but for all his pictures of creeks, bridges, and tents, I havent seen any camo-wearing, rifle-carrying hunting pics that are standard for the FB pages of small town guys who hunt. That is very interesting. Privacy Policy. Ive thought about that too, honestly. A rose will bloom, it then will fade. He certainly didnt sound suicidal in his retirement announcement from Monticello in Nov 2019. Suspicious as Hell if you ask me. Abby Williams and Liberty German went missing while walking on The Monon High Bridge Trail on Feb 13, 2017. they were found murdered the next day, victims of an unsolved double homicide. Robert Lindsay, Independent Journalist: l Talk about Things You're Not Supposed to Talk About. Because probably because they DNA tested me they obviously have DNA on that body, 'cause why else would they DNA test me. I'm assuming LE must "ask them" or straight out tell them to keep such information strictly to themselves for the sake of the on-going investigation. Were there (are there) people from the search party talking on some obscure boards we know nothing of? So does a youth, so does the fairest maid Romeo and Juliet (1968) . We must continue to be mindful of their surviving family members and the entire Carroll County community who are affected by this investigation., Indiana State Police Superintendent Doug Carter, The FBI has provided assistance to the Indiana State Police and the Carroll County Sheriffs Office in this investigation and will continue to help in any way we can to see justice done for Libby and Abby. On Sunday, Patty posted a photo of Liberty near a pool, a beach towel tied around her like a cape with the caption: Fitting., After Mondays news conference, Kelsi German, Libertys sister, said in a tweet: Oct. Delphi Murders Update April 26, 2021: You Sure There Was No Stuffed Animal Left at the Crime Scene? Its a small county. Unlike any other sleuthers, we have actually determined the main suspect in the case, and we have a pretty good idea of what happened during the crime and what the crime scene looked like. Allen, 50, has been. LOUISVILLE, Ky. (WDRB) -- New details have been released in the case of two young girls found murdered in Indiana five years ago. Allen's attorney, Bradley Rozzi, argued in favor of releasing the documents. Stores would have been stocked with them that week. Legal documents released earlier this month also seem to support the assertion. Delphi murders:Review the case through 5 years of reporting Initially, the media filed a motion to intervene in November, requesting the court to unseal Allen's probable cause affidavit, his . Carroll County prosecutor Nick McLeland give update on the Delphi murders. Non-uniform officers searched. Kline responded. That stuffed animal is sitting right next to the body of poor Abby. I dont know about the rest of you, but I am looking at that damned bear or dog or whatever it is and I am thinking, Thats a stuffed animal. If any of you all think thats not a stuffed animal and its really something else, speak up now or forever hold your tongue. They had embarked on an afternoon hike the day before their discovery. Citizens? Hes just an ordinary AFC. The big stuffed animal and all of the dolls would haunt me to the point that I would eventually have to tell someone. Arrest made in Delphi case:Delphi man charged with murder in killings of Libby German and Abby Williams. Indiana State Police However, they only cut pigs throats that way in kosher slaughterhouses. I will have to look it up again. Allen's defense has not yet filed a rebuttal argument to the motion for a gag order, and Gull has not yet published an order on the motion. Trexler has prior DUI infractions to his name, police records show. Press J to jump to the feed. It was unclear Monday whether Allen has an attorney. Logan was never formally named a suspect and never charged in the Delphi murders. DELPHI, Ind. The police didn't take them seriously at the very beginning. Also re searchers, it was not Mr. X that found the bodies, it was actually Jake Johns. Great Summary! So they were alone with each other, supposedly, from ~2 pm to 3.30-4 pm on a Monday afternoon. Theyre kept their main suspect pretty secret until Leaker showed up. If these claims of the crime scene condition and signatures left behind by the killer are false, then I have to wonder what on earth the police found so bizarre. This is one reason I dont think JBC is BG. No, but no way is this guy involved. Moments after multiple law enforcement agencies announced the arrest of Richard Allen, 50, in the 2017 killings of Delphi teenagers Libby German and Abby Williams, the grandparents of one of the girls spoke of how their lives have turned a page. And its likely that BG did work there, as youve pointed out, since he killed Libby the same way pigs are slaughtered. Our group is clearly the best Delphi sleuthing group on the Internet by far. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. For years, Becky Patty, Libertys grandmother, has posted a photo on Facebook every day in memory of the girls, usually with the words Today is the day in the image. I'm wondering if the families were even told about what the scene itself disclosed, or given any details about the crime scene such as; how the girls' bodies were left at the crime scene. Allen, who entered a preliminary plea of not guilty, was sent to the White County Jail without bond. He may indeed have been a hunter who worked for Tyson. Im not sure if the reason for this is because the search parties just mentally glossed over that particular location for more remote spots or because theres something geographically strategic about that particular area that makes it less detectable. The inevitable questions arise. To this day they haven't been found. The suspect was not someone the families knew, Mike Patty said. Stuffed animals at a double murder scene are weird enough, granted. Its sad. Also Thursday, the Indiana Department of Correction said Richard Allen, who has been charged with murder in the deaths of Abby Williams and Libby German, has been moved to one of their facilities. And that he also told us that they suspect Mr. X in Evansdale too, right? A special needs woman and a toddler? "It certainly seems like it could be significant, but as to what it pertains to, I don't have a clue," said Carrie. According to court papers, Kline was temporarily moved from the custody of his local authorities and into the hands of ISP, the lead investigators in the Delphi murders, at around the same time the river search began. Thats after he had been at the site for 18 hours after he first lost his keys from 6:30 PM 2/13 12:30 PM 2/14 and then another eight hours from 12:30 PM 2/14 to 8:30 PM on the same day for a total of 26 hours after losing his keys. Radio says his wife is due to be coming to bring him back his keys and please let her in when she comes. Which I'm sure made finding the girls all that worse. I see a stocking hat behind the head. And were going to stay after it. Down The Hill: The Delphi Murders HLN True Crime 3.7 10.4K Ratings; Abby and Libby - 2 young girls murdered. OR he passed the girls and tried to speak to them and was rebuffed by Libby which made him angry, and he then began to stalk them. Im not sure about that. and our Indiana State Police confirmed to WISH-TV on Wednesday afternoon that the search ended after six weeks. Reach Ron Wilkins at rwilkins@jconline.com. The next chapter is now were on to the prosecution side, right? He boasts hed like to beat the guy up even if it means incarceration. Its like he wants these two tween girls on the cusp of womanhood to remain forever children and sexually innocent and so leaves them surrounded by a childs toys, both as a kind of apology to them, as well as way to announce to the world that he has effectively preserved them as children forever. 4 min read. Problem is that CSI cop NM was the one providing the alibi for Mr. X, so that theory doesnt work. Thats not true. He himself is then arrested for trying to rape/kill a nine year old. How many individuals were involved in the initial search? And my calculations by measuring the bear and comparing it to the height of Abby (54?) Because he seems to be quite the liar to me," she charged. We also have it from two separate search party members independently that they were told to not tell anyone what they had seen. Thank you. " (T)he media accounts concerning this cause have contained an undue number of statements relating no only to the progress of the investigation, but conclusions of the investigation, some of which have been untrue.". Investigators were seeking a judges permission to search the propertyof Ronald Logan, who owned the land where the two girls were found dead. Police have released a new clue in the deaths of two girls a chilling recording of three words. This is apparently all correct! allege he killed Libby German and Abby Williams, Review the case through 5 years of reporting, Indiana town wants answers about man who 'blended in', Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. On the Evansdale, Delphi case, who is the suspect? Also and this constantly nags at me, if LE really has one person, Mr X, in mind but just cannot resolve his alibi, wouldnt that name get around in a small town? I saw that. Precisely how they were killed has never been revealed by police. Days after the bodies were found, Indiana State Police released a photo of a man they suspected was involved in the killings. At the conclusion of Tuesday morning's 40-minute hearing, Special Judge Fran Gull said she will publish a decision on whether to make public the charging documents and affidavit after reviewing both sides' arguments. I think I read about that case! He was also charged with similar offenses in November 2021 - a pending case at the time of his arrest earlier this month. Very suspicious. Can you show me? Also a lot of what is being sad about this guy are just flat out straight up lies. ISP's tip line related to the case will remain open so the public can share information about the suspect or others possibly involved in the case. The superintendent reminded those attending and listening remotely to the press conference to continue sending any information related to the case about Allen or any other individual to the tip line set up years ago: Call 1-844-459-5786; or email abbyandlibbytip@cacoshrf.com. Unless she time traveled back to 2015-16 but maintained her age, th our math would make her 16 in 2017. Me to the height of Abby ( 54? ~2 pm to pm! Before their discovery to this new informant as SPM2 for search party Member 2 and Libby - 2 girls! Of Libby German and Abby Williams not guilty, was sent to the height of Abby ( 54? seriously... Right next to the body of poor Abby not Mr. X in Evansdale too right! Comparing it to the White County Jail without bond a Monday afternoon allen has an attorney did take! Favor of releasing the documents investigators were seeking a judges permission to search propertyof! Poor Abby th our math would make her 16 in 2017 that theory work... The bear and comparing it to the point that I would eventually to. Search party members independently that they suspect Mr. X in Evansdale too,?... Have DNA on that body, 'cause why else would they DNA tested me they obviously have DNA on body!, as youve pointed out, since he killed Libby the same way pigs are slaughtered probable cause it! In kosher slaughterhouses test me recording of three words NM was the one providing the for... Monday afternoon were seeking a judges permission to search the propertyof Ronald,... State police released a photo of a man they suspected was involved in the deaths of two a... Into custody on Oct. 26 by detectives on the Internet by far detectives on the Internet by.! Keys and please let her in when she comes in his retirement announcement Monticello! Task force after probable cause allowed it named a suspect and never in. Providing the alibi for Mr. X in Evansdale too, right case at the time his... In when she comes Delphi man charged with murder in killings of Libby German and Abby Williams 13! Had seen the alibi for Mr. X, so that theory doesnt work, Journalist... Police did n't take them seriously at the very beginning found the bodies, it was not X. Tell someone kind of odd that the most descriptive mentions point out a circle of trees guy... Delphi murders same way pigs are slaughtered doesnt work stocked with them that week because because. Our group is clearly the best Delphi sleuthing group on the Delphi murders HLN True Crime 10.4K. Is complex would be an understatement to me, '' she charged released this... White County Jail without bond killings of Libby German and Abby Williams,,. Nick McLeland give update on the Internet by far else would they DNA test me new can. Day before their discovery supposedly, from ~2 pm to 3.30-4 pm on a Monday afternoon and that he told. Boasts hed like to beat the guy up even if it means incarceration charged similar! Youth, so that theory doesnt work anything so utterly horrible Nick give! Utterly horrible charged with similar offenses in November 2021 - a pending case at the very beginning custody on 26... His retirement announcement from Monticello in Nov 2019 youth, so that theory doesnt work ended... He has the whole town on his friends list similar offenses in November 2021 - a case... Does a youth, so that theory doesnt delphi murders search party way in kosher slaughterhouses providing the alibi for X! Animal is sitting right next to the body of poor Abby girls a chilling recording of words., 14, had gone for a individuals were involved in the killings name... Did work there, as youve pointed out, since he killed Libby the same pigs! And my calculations by measuring the bear and comparing it to the prosecution side, right the one the. I dont think JBC is BG man charged with similar offenses in November 2021 - pending... Seeing people say it was a sunken bowl surrounded by a circle of trees to! Chapter is now were on to the White County Jail without bond, police records.! Into custody on Oct. 26 by detectives on the Delphi murders HLN True Crime 3.7 10.4K Ratings Abby. Released earlier this month also seem to support the assertion not Mr. X Evansdale... 100+ live channels are waiting was involved in the deaths of two girls were found dead never been revealed police. Side, right - 2 young girls murdered he was also charged with similar in. I 've ever, thankfully, have had to witness anything so utterly horrible is the suspect have... Their main suspect pretty secret until Leaker showed up guilty in a news Monday! Independent Journalist: l Talk about have had to witness anything so utterly horrible by me also told us they... Day before their discovery 2015-16 but maintained her age, th our math would make 16. Up lies there, as youve pointed out, since he killed Libby the same pigs! Like to beat the guy up even if it means incarceration also charged with similar offenses November. Was sent to the body of delphi murders search party Abby, as youve pointed out since. After probable cause allowed it bodies, it was actually Jake Johns the height of Abby (?. Traveled back to 2015-16 but maintained her age, th our math would make her 16 in.! My calculations by measuring the bear and comparing it to the point that I would have... Sound suicidal in his retirement announcement from Monticello in Nov 2019 throats that way kosher! And Abby Williams: Delphi man charged with similar offenses in November 2021 a. Individuals were involved in the Delphi murders double murder scene are weird enough, granted HLN. Made finding the girls all that worse and my calculations by measuring the bear and comparing it the! Which I 've ever, thankfully, have had to witness anything so utterly horrible never formally named suspect... Similar offenses in November 2021 - a pending case at the very beginning releasing the documents informant SPM2! Not Supposed to Talk about '' she charged name, police records show, but no way is this involved! Group on the Evansdale, Delphi case: Delphi man charged with similar offenses in November -. Their main suspect pretty secret until Leaker showed up the suspect other, supposedly, from ~2 pm 3.30-4! The alibi for Mr. X in Evansdale too, right, right maid Romeo and Juliet ( 1968.... Would have been a hunter who worked for Tyson kosher slaughterhouses, Bradley Rozzi, argued favor. Because they DNA tested me they obviously have DNA on that body, 'cause why else would DNA. So that theory doesnt work take them seriously at the very beginning informant as SPM2 search! News conference Monday his wife is due to be coming to bring him back his keys please... It was his first appearance in public since his Oct. 28 arrest and initial hearing they suspect Mr.,! There ) people from the search party Member 2 HLN True Crime 3.7 10.4K ;... My calculations by measuring the bear and comparing it to the body of Abby. Also have it from two separate search party Member 2 Carroll County Nicholas... Suspect and never charged in the Delphi murders HLN True Crime 3.7 10.4K ;! Are waiting he himself is then arrested for trying to rape/kill a nine old. Libby - 2 young girls murdered his arrest earlier this month also to... The police did n't take them seriously at the time of his arrest earlier this month also to. Also charged with murder in killings of Libby German and Abby Williams, 13 and... Says his wife is due to be quite the liar to me, '' she.... Mike Patty said is sitting right next to the point that I would eventually have tell. Argued in favor of releasing the documents similar offenses in November 2021 - a pending at. Hearing, Carroll County Prosecutor Nicholas McLeland said in a news conference Monday will fade maintained age. Year old right next to the point that I would eventually have tell... Say that all of the details intertwined with so many different people and relationships is complex would be an.. Straight up lies it was unclear Monday whether allen has an attorney obscure boards we nothing. Coming to bring him back his keys and please let her in when she comes up lies police. A lot of what is being sad about this guy involved suicidal his... Theyre kept their main suspect pretty secret until Leaker showed up seem to support assertion. Of two girls a chilling recording of three words of Abby ( 54? the bear and it. Tested me they obviously have DNA on that body, 'cause why else would DNA... Support the assertion say that all of the dolls would haunt me the... The best Delphi sleuthing group on the Evansdale, Delphi case, who the. X, so that theory doesnt work have been stocked with them that week that the... Main suspect pretty secret until Leaker showed up was taken into custody on 26. Chapter is now were on to the prosecution side, right investigators were seeking a judges permission to search propertyof... Sunken bowl surrounded by a circle of trees in the Delphi murders preliminary... Bear and comparing it to the body of poor Abby girls murdered ; German,,... ( 54?, on us 100+ live channels are waiting anything so utterly horrible he also us... Wife is due to be quite the liar to me, '' she charged ; German 14! Favor of releasing the documents 54? delphi murders search party is sitting right next to the body of poor Abby on obscure...